Differences between revisions 3 and 7 (spanning 4 versions)
⇤ ← Revision 3 as of 2007-04-09 22:03:16 →
Size: 1705
Editor: yakko
Comment:
← Revision 7 as of 2007-04-09 22:20:55 → ⇥
Size: 2246
Editor: yakko
Comment:
Deletions are marked like this. Additions are marked like this.
Line 5: Line 5:
Apparently implemented <= instead of >=. Consequently one of my simple tests does not run. However it appears that he implemented the correct procedure and other than the above it look good. Apparently you implemented <= instead of >=. This should not be a problem, however the satisfiable tests fail. It appears that you implemented the correct procedure (SAT for Addition constraints not just difference constraints) and other than the above it look good. I would like to see you about a possible better grade. If you can show me that you can modify my tests to pass, I'll give you a 20/20.
Line 7: Line 7:
testSimpleSat: Failed
testSimpleUnsat: Passed
testDiffUnsat: Passed
testDiff2Sat: Failed
testAddUnsat: Passed
testAddSat: Failed		    * testSimpleSat: Failed
   * testSimpleUnsat: Passed
   * testDiffUnsat: Passed
   * testDiff2Sat: Failed
   * testAddUnsat: Passed
   * testAddSat: Failed
Line 14: Line 14:
3/6

18		 Recommend: 18
Line 22: Line 20:
testSimpleSat: Passed
testSimpleUnsat: Passed
testDiffUnsat: Passed
testDiff2Sat: Passed
testAddUnsat: Failed
testAddSat: Failed		    * testSimpleSat: Passed
   * testSimpleUnsat: Passed
   * testDiffUnsat: Passed
   * testDiff2Sat: Passed
   * testAddUnsat: Failed
   * testAddSat: Failed
Line 29: Line 27:
4/6

17		 Recommend: 17
Line 36: Line 32:
You only implemented difference constraints. But a very nice program interface! Passes all difference tests. Fails x+y>=b tests and -x-y>=b tests. You only implemented difference constraints. But a very nice program interface!
Line 38: Line 34:
testSimpleSat: Passed
testSimpleUnsat: Failed
testDiffUnsat: Failed
testDiff2Sat: Passed		    * testSimpleSat: Passed
   * testSimpleUnsat: Passed
   * testDiffUnsat: Passed
   * testDiff2Sat: Passed
   * testAddUnsat: Failed
   * testAddSat: Failed
Line 43: Line 41:
Although I'm not absolutely certain, I belive you are not reaching a fixpoint when you use log10 in the satisfiable method. 4/6
Line 45: Line 43:
2/6

18 		Recommend: 18
Line 51: Line 47:
You only implemented difference constraints. Passes all difference tests. Fails x+y>=b tests and -x-y>=b tests. You only implemented difference constraints.
Line 53: Line 49:
18    * testSimpleSat: Passed
   * testSimpleUnsat: Passed
   * testDiffUnsat: Passed
   * testDiff2Sat: Passed
   * testAddUnsat: Failed
   * testAddSat: Failed

4/6

Recommend: 17
Line 59: Line 64:
testSimpleSat: Passed
testSimpleUnsat: Passed
testDiffUnsat: Passed
testDiff2Sat: Passed
testAddUnsat: Failed
testAddSat: Failed		    * testSimpleSat: Passed
   * testSimpleUnsat: Passed
   * testDiffUnsat: Passed
   * testDiff2Sat: Passed
   * testAddUnsat: Failed
   * testAddSat: Failed
Line 66: Line 71:
18 Recommend: 17
Line 72: Line 77:
testSimpleSat: Passed
testSimpleUnsat: Passed
testDiffUnsat: Passed
testDiff2Sat: Passed
testAddUnsat: Failed
testAddSat: Failed		    * testSimpleSat: Passed
   * testSimpleUnsat: Passed
   * testDiffUnsat: Passed
   * testDiff2Sat: Passed
   * testAddUnsat: Failed
   * testAddSat: Failed
Line 80: Line 85:
18 Recommend: 17
Line 86: Line 91:
   * testSimpleSat: Passed
   * testSimpleUnsat: Passed
   * testDiffUnsat: Passed
   * testDiff2Sat: Passed
   * testAddUnsat: Failed
   * testAddSat: Failed
Line 87: Line 98:

18		 Recommend: 17

This is remarks for grading the project:

Hodges

Apparently you implemented <= instead of >=. This should not be a problem, however the satisfiable tests fail. It appears that you implemented the correct procedure (SAT for Addition constraints not just difference constraints) and other than the above it look good. I would like to see you about a possible better grade. If you can show me that you can modify my tests to pass, I'll give you a 20/20.

  • testSimpleSat: Failed
  • testSimpleUnsat: Passed
  • testDiffUnsat: Passed
  • testDiff2Sat: Failed
  • testAddUnsat: Passed
  • testAddSat: Failed

Recommend: 18

Augustyn

Implemented the book sat method which only does difference constraints.

  • testSimpleSat: Passed
  • testSimpleUnsat: Passed
  • testDiffUnsat: Passed
  • testDiff2Sat: Passed
  • testAddUnsat: Failed
  • testAddSat: Failed

Recommend: 17

Yue

You only implemented difference constraints. But a very nice program interface!

  • testSimpleSat: Passed
  • testSimpleUnsat: Passed
  • testDiffUnsat: Passed
  • testDiff2Sat: Passed
  • testAddUnsat: Failed
  • testAddSat: Failed

4/6

Recommend: 18

Sadofsky

You only implemented difference constraints.

  • testSimpleSat: Passed
  • testSimpleUnsat: Passed
  • testDiffUnsat: Passed
  • testDiff2Sat: Passed
  • testAddUnsat: Failed
  • testAddSat: Failed

4/6

Recommend: 17

Neo

You only implemented difference constraints.

  • testSimpleSat: Passed
  • testSimpleUnsat: Passed
  • testDiffUnsat: Passed
  • testDiff2Sat: Passed
  • testAddUnsat: Failed
  • testAddSat: Failed

Recommend: 17

Miao

You only implemented difference constraints.

  • testSimpleSat: Passed
  • testSimpleUnsat: Passed
  • testDiffUnsat: Passed
  • testDiff2Sat: Passed
  • testAddUnsat: Failed
  • testAddSat: Failed

Recommend: 17

Ramsey

You only implemented difference constraints. Passes all difference tests.

  • testSimpleSat: Passed
  • testSimpleUnsat: Passed
  • testDiffUnsat: Passed
  • testDiff2Sat: Passed
  • testAddUnsat: Failed
  • testAddSat: Failed

Recommend: 17

Cse913ProjS107 (last edited 2007-04-09 22:32:46 by yakko)